The Right to Cultural Identity in the Case Law of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights: A New Global Standard for the Protection of Indigenous Rights and Future Generations?
Abstract
This paper examines the protection of the right to cultural identity in the case law of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACtHR), where this question has appeared in connection with the rights of indigenous peoples. Although not expressly guaranteed in the American Convention on Human Rights (ACHR), the right to cultural identity has received protection in the IACtHR9s case law through an evolutionary interpretation of the rights to life and property, and other provisions under the ACHR. A landmark decision in the 2020 case of Lhaka Honhat Association v. Argentina has put into a new perspective the protection of the right to cultural identity. For the first time, it was clearly established that cultural rights are autonomous and judicially enforceable under Article 26 of the ACHR. The ICtHR9s revolutionary approach offers new opportunities for the judicial protection of environmental rights claims, contributing to the debate on sustainable development and the protection of future generations as well. The ICtHR has risen to be a regional standard-setting treaty body in the Inter-American system. Simultaneously, its far-reaching approach to protecting cultural identity and land rights has made the IACtHR9s case law a genuine reference point for other universal and regional international human rights organs.
References
Antkowiak T M (2013) Rights, Resources, and Rhetoric: Indigenous Peoples and the Inter-American Court, University of Pennsylvania Journal of International Law, 35(1), pp. 113–187.
Barelli M (2018) Free, Prior and Informed Consent in the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. Articles 10, 19, 29(2) and 32(2), in: Hanson J & Weller M, eds., The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. A Commentary, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 247–272.
Bándi Gy (2020) A fenntartható fejlődés és az őshonos nemzeti kisebbségek, in: Dabis A, ed., Magyarok jogvédelme a Kárpát-medencében 2020, Kisebbségi Jogvédő Intézet, Budapest, pp. 11–44.
Bándi Gy (2022) Sustainable Development, the Interests of Future Generations, and Moral and Legal Implications, in: Szilágyi J E, ed., Constitutional Protection of the Environment and Future Generations. Legislation and Practice in Certain Central European Countries, Central European Academic Publishing, Miskolc, Budapest, pp. 17–71, doi: https://doi.org/10.54237/profnet.2022.jeszcpefg_2
Cançado Trindade A A (2009) The Right to Cultural Identity in the Evolving Jurisprudential Construction of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, in: Yee S & Morin J-Y, eds., Multiculturalism and International Law, Koninklijke Brill NV, Boston, Leiden, pp. 477–499. doi: https://doi.org/10.1163/ej.9789004174719.i-772.144
Castellino J & Cathal D (2018) Who Are 8Indigenous Peoples9?: An Examination of Concepts Concerning Group Membership in the UNDRIP, in: Hanson J & Weller M, eds., The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. A Commentary, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 7–37.
Charters C (2018) Indigenous Peoples9 Rights to Lands, Territories and Resources in the UNDRIP. Articles 10, 25, 26 and 27, in: Hanson J & Weller M, eds., The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. A Commentary, Oxford University Pres, Oxford, pp. 395–397.
Domaradzki S, Khvostova M & Pupovac D (2019) Karel Vasak9s Generations of Rights and the Contemporary Human Rights Discourse, Human Rights Review, 20(4), pp. 423–443, doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12142-019-00565-x
Donders Y (2008) A Right to Cultural Identity in UNESCO, in: Francioni F & Schein M, eds., Cultural Human Rights, Koninklijke Brill NV, Boston, Leiden, pp. 317–340.
Errico S (2018) Control over Natural Resources and Protection of the Environment of Indigenous Territories. Articles 29, 30 and 32, in: Hanson J & Weller M, eds., The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. A Commentary, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 425–460.
Hanson J (2018) The UNDRIP and the Rights of Indigenous Peoples to Existence, Cultural Integrity and Identity, and Non-Assimilation. Articles 7(2), 8 and 43, in: Hanson J & Weller M, eds., The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. A Commentary, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 150–178.
Krznaric R (2020) The Good Ancestor. A Radical Prescription for Long-Term Thinking, The Experiment, New York.
Marinkás Gy (2020) The Right to a Healthy Environment as a Basic Human Right – Possible Approaches Based on the Practice of the Human Rights Mechanisms, with Special Regard to the Issues of Indigenous Peoples, Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Law, 15(29), pp. 133–151, doi: https://doi.org/10.21029/JAEL.2020.29.133
Martínez Cobo J R (1972) Study of the Problem of Discrimination against Indigenous Populations, 29 June 1972, E/CN.4/Sub.2/L.566.
Pasqualucci J M (2008) The Right to a Dignified Life (Vida Digna): The Integration of Economic and Social Rights with Civil and Political Rights in the Inter-American Human Rights System, Hastings International and Comparative Law Review, 31(1), pp. 1–32.
Pasqualucci J M (2013) The practice and procedure of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, Cambridge University Press, New York. doi: https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511843884
Raisz A (2008) Indigenous Communities before the Inter-American Court of Human Rights – New Century, New Era?, Miskolc Journal of International Law, 5(2), pp. 35–51.
Raisz A (2010) Az emberi jogok amerikaközi védelme, Publicationes Universitatis Miskolcinensis. Sectio Juridica et Politica, vol. 28, pp. 281–295.
Ruiz-Chiriboga O (2006) The Right to Cultural Identity of Indigenous Peoples and National Minorities: A Look from the Inter-American System, SUR-International Journal on Human Rights, 3(5), pp. 43–69.
Ruiz-Chiriboga O (2013) The American Convention and the Protocol of San Salvador: Two Intertwined Treaties - Non-Enforceability of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in the Inter-American System, Netherlands Quarterly of Human Rights, 31(2), pp. 159–186, doi: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.1940559
Shelton D (2015) Remedies in International Human Rights Law, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Symonides J (2000) Cultural Rights, in: Symonides J, ed., Human Rights: Concept and Standards, Ashgate, Aldershot, pp. 175–227.
Szilágyi J E (2021) Some Values and Guarantees in the Ten-Year-Old Hungarian Constitution, With a Look at the Constitutional Arrangements of the Countries Founding the European Integration, Central European Journal of Comparative Law, 2(2), pp. 197–219, doi: https://doi.org/10.47078/2021.2.197-219
Szilágyi J E (2022) Constitutional Protection of the Environment and Future Generations in Certain Central European Countries, in: Szilágyi J E, ed., Constitutional Protection of the Environment and Future Generations. Legislation and Practice in Certain Central European Countries, Central European Academic Publishing, Miskolc, Budapest, pp. 479–526, doi: https://doi.org/10.54237/profnet.2022.jeszcpefg_12
UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (CESCR), General Comment No. 26 on land and economic, social and cultural rights, adopted by the CESCR at its seventy-second session (26 September – 14 October 2022), E/C.12/GC/26.
UN Convention to Combat Desertification of Lands (2022) Global Land Outlook. Second Edition. Land Restoration for Recovery and Resilience, Bonn.
Xanthaki A (2018) Culture. Articles 11(1), 12, 13(1), and 34, in: Hanson J & Weller M, eds., The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. A Commentary, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 273–298.
Zombory K (2022) The Protection of Cultural Heritage in International Law, in: Raisz A, ed., International Law From a Central European Perspective, Central European Academic Publishing, Miskolc, Budapest, pp. 239–262, doi: https://doi.org/10.54171/2022.ar.ilfcec_11
