From Privatisation to Remunicipalisation: How Returning to Public Control of Water Services Benefits Hungarian Society

Keywords: water services, privatisation, public control, regulation, utilities, governance

Abstract

This article examines Hungary’s transition from the privatisation of water services in the early 1990s to a reassertion of public control by the 2010s. It situates Hungary’s trajectory within the broader context of post-Soviet Central and Eastern European reforms and explores the socio-economic and regulatory implications of privatising essential services without first establishing a stable market framework. Through a critical historical and legal analysis, the paper investigates the motivations behind water sector privatisation, the challenges encountered, and the subsequent remunicipalisation trend prompted by public dissatisfaction with private service delivery. The study highlights the continued primacy of national regulatory discretion in water governance across the European Union, in contrast to more centralised sectors such as energy or telecommunications. Comparative insights from countries like France, and the United Kingdom further contex- tualise Hungary’s experience. Ultimately, the paper evaluates whether the consolidation of water utilities and remunicipalisation efforts served the long-term interests of Hungar- ian society and contributed to more equitable and efficient water service provision.

References

Allouche J, Finger M & Luís–Manso P (2008) Water sector evolution scenarios: the case of Europe, Water Policy 10, pp. 221–238. doi: 10.2166/wp.2008.149.

Bándi G (2013) A fenntartható fejlődés jogáról, Pro Futuro 3(1), pp. 11–30.

Bányai O (2014) Energiajog az ökológiai fenntarthatóság szolgálatában, DELA Könyvkiadó és Kereskedelmi Kft, Debrecen.

Bauby P, Hecht C & Warm S (2018) Water remunicipalisation in Berlin and Paris: Specific processes and common challenges, CIRIEC Working Papers, 18(7), pp. 1–26.

Belényesi P (2014) Regulation of Water Services in EU – Recent Modifications in Hungary’s Regulatory Framework for Water Service Provision, European Networks Law and Regulation Quarterly 2(1), pp. 17–28.

Boda Z & Scheiring G (2006) Water privatisation in the context of transition, in: Chávez D (ed.) Beyond the market: Public services yearbook, Transnational Institute, Amsterdam, pp. 95–101.

Bolognesi T (2014b) The results of modernizing network industries: the case of urban water services in Europe, Competition and Regulation in Network Industries 15(4), pp. 371–391, doi: 10.1177/178359171401500401.

Bolognesi T. (2014a) The paradox of the modernisation of urban water systems in Europe: Intrinsic institutional limits for sustainability, Natural Resources Forum 38 (4), pp. 270–281, doi: 10.1111/1477–8947.12052

Cohen D (2016) The history of privatization: How an ideological and political attack on government became a corporate grab for gold, TPM Features, 9 September, http://talkingpointsmemo.com/features/privatization/one/ [04.11.2024]

European Parliament (2003) Report on the Green Paper on services of general interest A5–0484/2003, 21 May, https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/ document/A–5–2003–0484_EN.html [14.02.2017]

Ferro G, Lentini E J & Mercadier A C (2011) Economies of scale in the water sector: a survey of the empirical literature, Journal of Water, Sanitation and Hygiene for Development 1, pp.179–193, doi:10.2166/washdev.2011.041.

Financing Water For All (2003) Report of the world panel on financing water infrastructure, 1 March, https://www.worldwatercouncil.org/en/publications/ financing–water–all [13.09.2024]

Fodor L (2013) A víz az alaptörvény környezeti értékrendjében, Publicationes Universitatis Miskolciensis, Sectio Juridica et Politica 31, pp. 329–345.

Frontier Economics (2014) Improving economic regulation of urban water: A report orepared for the water services association of Australia, 26 August, https://ppp.worldbank.org/public–private–partnership/applicable–all– sectors/library [22.08.2024]

Hall D & Lobina E (2004) Private and public interests in water and energy, Natural Resources Forum 28, pp. 268–277, doi: 10.1111/j.1477–8947.2004.00100.x

Harvey D (2005) A Brief History of Neoliberalism, Oxford Academic, Oxford, doi: 10.1093/oso/9780199283262.001.0001

Herrera V & Post A E (2014) Can developing countries both decentralize and depoliticize urban water services? Evaluating the legacy of the 1990s reform wave, World Development 64, pp. 621–641, doi: 10.1016/j.worlddev.2014.06.026

Horváth M T (1997) Public Services, Private Organization – Privatization in Municipalities, Hungarian Public Administration 5, pp. 257–267.

Kerr T M (1995) Supplying water infrastructure to developing countries via private sector project financing, Georgetown International Environmental Law Review 8, pp. 91–108.

Kis A & Ungvári G (2019) Are we still falling? Sustainability and equity in the Hungarian water utility services sector, Budapest Management Review 50, pp. 77–91, doi: 10.14267/VEZTUD.2019.KSZ.07

Koncz I K (2019) The development of water rights administration in Hungary, JAEL 14(27), pp. 103–111. doi: 10.21029/JAEL.2019.27.103.

Központi Statisztikai Hivatal (2020) Közüzemi vezetékes ivóvízzel ellátott települések és lakások, https://www.ksh.hu/docs/hun/xstadat/xstadat_eves/i_ zrk001.html [13.09.2024]

Központi Statisztikai Hivatal (2022) A közüzemi vezetékes ivóvízzel ellátott lakások száma, https://www.ksh.hu/s/kiadvanyok/fenntarthato–fejlodes– indikatorai–2022/1–11–sdg–6 [13.09.2024]

Központi Statisztikai Hivatal (2023) Települések infrastrukturális ellátottsága 2023, https://www.ksh.hu/s/kiadvanyok/telepulesek–infrastrukturalis– ellatottsaga–2023/index.html [13.09.2024]

Központi Statisztikai Hivatal (2024) Környezet, kommunális ellátás, 23 December, https://www.ksh.hu/kornyezet–kommunalis–ellatas [13.09.2024]

Kristiansen M (1996) Incorporating environmental law in the context of privatization transactions in Hungary, Poland, and Russia, Administrative Law Review 48(4), pp. 627–644.

Lobina E, Hall D (2008) Hungary, in: Prasad N (ed.) Social policies and private sector participation in water supply, Palgrave Macmillan, London, pp. 178–202.

Magyarország Kormánya (2021) Lehetővé vált a Nemzeti Vízművek integrációs folyamatához való csatlakozás, 16 July, https://kormany.hu/hirek/lehetove– valt–a–nemzeti–vizmuvek–integracios–folyamatahoz–valo–csatlakozas [09.09.2023]

MEKH (2018) A víziközmű működési engedélyes szolgáltatók listája, 15 May, https://www.e–gepesz.hu/hirek/17230–vizikozmu–mukodesi–engedelyes– szolgaltatok–listaja [14.09.2024]

Nagy Z (2019) The question of water and management of water resources from the point of view of domestic environmental financial regulations, JAEL 14(26), pp. 171–173. doi: 10.21029/JAEL.2019.26.162.

Opazo T (2016) The boys who got to remake an economy, Slate, 12 January, https:// tinyurl.com/7j36fuvz [13.09.2024]

Petrova V (2006) All the frontiers of the rush for blue gold: Water privatization and the human right to water, Brooklyn Journal of International Law 31 (2), pp. 577–613.

PSIRU (2012) Researches the privatisation and restructuring of public services around the world, with special focus on water, energy, waste management, and healthcare, 18 May, https://www.gre.ac.uk/ [24.10.2024]

Raisz A (2012) A constitution’s environment, environment in the constitution, Est Europa, Special Edition 1, pp. 37–70.

Ramos E (2017) The dangers of water privatization: An exploration of the discriminatory practices of private water companies, Environmental and Earth Law Journal 7, pp. 188–217.

Saal D, Parker D, Weyman–Jones T (2007) Determining the contribution of technical change, efficiency change and scale change to productivity growth in the privatized English and Welsh water and sewerage industry: 1985–2000, Journal of Productivity Analysis 28, pp. 127–139, doi: 10.1007/s11123–007–0040–z.

Sax J L (2008) Understanding transfers: Community rights and the privatization of water, Hastings West–Northwest Journal of Environmental Law and Policy, 14(1), pp. 33–40.

Szabo I & Quesada M G (2017) Historical waves in Hungarian water sector reform and implications for integration, Utilities Policy 46, pp. 15–21, doi: 10.1016/j.jup.2017.02.005.

Szilágyi J E (2013) Vízjog – Aktuális kihívások a vizek jogi szabályozásában. Mickolc: University of Miskolc.

Szilágyi J E (2014) A magyar víziközmű–szolgáltatók integrációja jogi nézőpontból, Pro Futuro 4(1), pp. 144–162.

Szilágyi J E (2016) Current challenges concerning the law of water services in Hungary, Lex et Scientia 23(1), pp. 70–82.

Szilágyi J E (2018) Vízszemléletű kormányzás – vízpolitika – vízjog: kitekintéssel a vízgazdálkodásra és a víztudományra, University of Miskolc, Miskolc.

The Economist (2003) Stagnant: Water companies mop up capital and leak profits, Britain section, 31 July, https://www.economist.com/britain/2003/07/31/ stagnant [13.09.2024]

Ungvári G & Koskovics É (2010) Áttekintés a magyar víziközmű–ágazatról, in: Valentiny, P., Kiss F L & Nagy Cs I (eds.) Verseny és Szabályozás, Regionális Energiagazdálkodási Kutatóközpont, Budapest, pp. 305–328.

Van den Berge J, Boelens R & Vos J (2020) How the European Citizens’ Initiative ‘Water and Sanitation is a Human Right! Changed EU Discourse on Water Services Provision’, Utrecht Law Review 16, pp. 48–59, doi: 10.36633/ulr.568

Wackerbauer J (2007) Regulation and privatisation of the public water supply in England, France and Germany, Competition and Regulation in Network Industries 8, pp. 101–116, doi: 10.1177/178359170700800201.

Wade J S (2008) Privatization and the future of water services, Florida Journal of International Law 20(4), pp. 179–200.

Published
2025-06-25
Section
Cikkek