Kin-state politics stirred by a geopolitical conflict: Hungary's growing activity in post-Euromaidan Transcarpathia, Ukraine
Abstract
In the last decades, as a result of intensified migratory movements, scholars have globally witnessed the proliferation of transnational migrant and diaspora communities in many cases challenging the traditionally conceived sovereignty of nation states and inducing policy answers in the field of migration and citizenship politics. In Central and Eastern European countries, citizenship issues have been embedded in kin-state politics due to the existence of great number of ethnic-kin communities living in the territory of a neighbouring or nearby host countries. That is especially true to Hungary that has elaborated a sophisticated system of kin-state policies composing inseparable factor both in its domestic and foreign politics. The ongoing crisis in Ukraine generated such push factors that resulted in boosting out-migration in its westernmost region, Transcarpathia, where sizeable ethnic Hungarian community resides. The out-migration is further facilitated by pull factors manifested in intensified political presence and kin-state politics of Hungary, Poland and Czechia, three Visegrad countries in need of fresh labour force. The present paper - after reviewing recent migratory processes - offers an analysis on the interrelatedness of migration, geopolitics and kin-state politics in Transcarpathia.
We argue that Ukraine's crisis resulted in a major shift in regional geopolitical power relations opening the floor to the Visegrad countries to intensify their presence and influence in Western Ukraine, primarily seeking for human resources to satisfy their demographic and workforce needs. Focusing on Hungary, we intend to prove that the out-migration of Transcarpathian Hungarians posed a serious challenge to the well-built system of Hungarian kin-state policies resulting in major modification of measures targeting Transcarpathia. We point to the ambiguous nature of the prime kin-state policy measure, the dual citizenship without residency introduced in 2010 by Hungary, arguing that following 2014 in the post Euromaidan Transcarpathian context it represents a tempting pragmatic tool embodying practical opportunities, even material benefits attractive for all Transcarpathians, including non-ethnic Hungarians. Finally, we conclude that Hungary's kin-state politics not only contribute to the decrease of the number of Transcarpathian Hungarians, but there is a high risk that - with their Hungarian citizenship - they will resettle in Western Europe, not in Hungary.
References
Agarin, T. and Karolewski, I.P. 2015. Extraterritorial Citizenship in Postcommunist Europe. London, Rowman & Littlefield.
Bárdi, N. 2011. The Policy of Budapest Governments towards Hungarian Communities Abroad. In Minority Hungarian Communities in the Twentieth Century. Eds.: Bárdi, N., Fedinec, Cs. and Szarka, L., New York, Columbia University Press, 456-467.
Bárdi, N. 2016. A budapesti kormányzatok magyarságpolitikája (Kin-state politics of Hungarian governments). Paper presented at the conference "A megmaradás útjai - helyzetkép a külhoni magyarságról" in Budapest, 30 May 2016. Bauböck, R. 2007. The trade-off between transnational citizenship and political autonomy. In Dual citizenship in Global Perspective. Eds.: Faist, T. and Kivisto, P., New York, Palgrave -MacMillan, 69-91.
Bauböck, R., Ersboll, E., Groenendijk, K. and Waldrauch, H. 2009. Citizenship Policies in the New Europe. IMISCOE Research. Amsterdam, Amsterdam University Press.
Blaskó, Z. and Fazekas, K. eds. 2016. Munkaerőpiaci tükör (Report on labour market). Budapest, MTA KRTK.
Brubaker, R. 1996. Nationalism Reframed: Nationhood and the National Question in the New Europe. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press. Crossref
Çaglar, A. and Gereöffy, A. 2008. Ukrainian Migration to Hungary: A Fine Balance between Migration Policies and Diaspora Politics. Journal of Immigrant & Refugee Studies 6. (3): 326-343. Crossref
Castles, S. and Davidson, A. 2000. Citizenship and Migration. Globalization and the Politics of Belonging. London, Palgrave-MacMillan.
Čermáková, D. 2014. Migration between the EU, V4 and Eastern Europe: the present situation and the possible future. The perspective of Czechia. In Forecasting Migration Between the EU, V4 and Eastern Europe. Impact of Visa abolition. Eds.: Jaroszewicz, M. and Lesińska, M., Warsaw, Centre for Eastern Studies, 109-121.
Csergő, Z. and Goldgeier, J. 2004. Virtual Nationalism in Comparative Context: How Unique Is the Hungarian Approach? Central European Political Science Review 16. 40-56.
Drbohlav, D. and Seidlová, M. 2016. Current Ukrainian migration to Czechia: Refuge for economic migrants rather than for refugees. In Ukrainian migration in times of crisis: Forced and labour mobility. Eds.: Drbohlav, D. and Jaroszewicz, M., Prague, Charles University, Faculty of Science, Department of Social Geography and Regional Development, 95-127.
Drbohlav, D. and Valenta, O. 2014. Czechia: the main immigration country in the V4. In: Discovering migration between Visegrad countries and Eastern Partners. Eds.: Erőss, Á. and Karácsonyi, D., Budapest, MTA RCAES Geographical Institute, 41-71.
Élő, A. 2016. Ukránok a spájzban (Ukrainians at the gate). Heti válasz, 22 Sept. 2016. 20-22.
EMN 2015. Determining labour shortages and the need for labour migration from third countries in the EU. Hungary. EMN Focussed Study.
Erőss, Á., Kovály, K. and Tátrai, P. 2016. Effects of the Ukrainian crisis in Transcarpathia: the Hungarian perspective . Warsaw, Centre of Migration Research, (CMR Working Papers 92). Available at:
Faist, T. and Kivisto, P. 2007. Dual citizenship in Global Perspective. New York, Palgrave-MacMillan.
Feischmidt, M. and Zakariás, I. 2010. Migráció és etnicitás. A mobilitás formái és politikái nemzeti és transznacionális térben (Migration and ethnicity. Forms and politics of migration in national and transnational space). In Etnicitás. Különbségteremtő társadalom. Ed.: Feischmidt, M., Budapest, Gondolat Kiadó-MTA Kisebbségkutató Intézet, 152-169.
Fowler, B. 2002. Fuzzing Citizenship, Nationalising Political Space: A Framework for Interpreting the Hungarian 'Status Law' as a New Form of Kin-state Policy in Central and Eastern Europe. Economic and Social Research Council Working Paper 40. (2): 177-238.
Hatvany, C. 2006. Legitimacy of Kin-State Politics: A Theoretical Approach. Regio: Minorities, Politics, Society 6. (1): 47-64.
Howard, M.J. 2009. The politics of citizenship in Europe. New York, Cambridge University Press. Crossref
Iordachi, C. 2013. EUDO Citizenship Observatory. Country Report: Romania . San Domenico di Fiesole: European University Institute.
Jaroszewicz, M. 2015. The migration of Ukrainians in times of crisis. Warsaw, Centre for Eastern Studies. (2016-10-10)
Jordan, P. and Klemenčić, M. 2003. Transcarpathia - Bridgehead or Periphery? Eurasian Geography and Economics 46. (7): 497-513. Crossref
Jóźwiak, I. 2014. Ethnicity, Labour and Mobility in the Contemporary Borderland. A Case Study of a Transcarpathian Township. Central and Eastern European Migration Review 3. (1): 27-39.
Jóźwiak, I. and Lugosi, N. 2016. The Role of Nationalist Narratives and Myths in the Changing Dynamics of Mobility between Ukraine and its Western Neighbours. In Social Geographical Challenges and Search for Adequate Answers in East-Central Europe of the 21st Century. Ed.: Berghauer, S., Berehove, 123-133.
Józwiak, I. and Piechowska, M. 2016. Crisis-driven Mobility between Ukraine and Poland. What Does the Available Data (Not) Tell Us . Warsaw, Centre of Migration Research, CMR Working Papers 99.
Kántor, Z. 2014. Hungary's Kin-State Politics, 2010-2014. Minority Studies 17. 23-32.
Kántor, Z. 2016: Nemzet, autonómia, kettős állampolgárság (Nation, autonomy, dual citizenship). Paper presented at the conference titled "A megmaradás
útjai - helyzetkép a külhoni magyarságról" in Budapest, 30 May 2016.
Karácsonyi, D. and Kincses, Á. 2010. Az elvándorlás hatása a kárpátaljai magyarság helyzetére (The effect of immigration on the situation of Transcarpathian Hungarian population). Földrajzi Közlemények 134. (1): 31-44.
Karácsonyi, D., Kocsis, K., Kovály, K., Molnár, J. and Póti, L. 2014. East-West dichotomy and political conflict in Ukraine - Was Huntington right? Hungarian Geographical Bulletin 63. (2): 99-134. Crossref
Karolewski, I.P. 2015. The Polish Charter: Extraterritorial Semi-Citizenship and Soft Power. In Extraterritorial Citizenship in Postcommunist Europe. Eds.: Agarin, T. and Karolewski, I.P., London, Rowman & Littlefield, 65-88.
Kincses, Á. 2015. International Migration Diversity in Hungary in the 2011 Population Census Data. Regional Statistics 5. (2): 108-124. Crossref
Kiss, T. 2015. Marginalizáció, etnikai párhuzamosság és aszimmetrikus akkomodáció. Az erdélyi magyar közösséget érintő társadalmi és politikai folyamatok (Marginalization, ethnic parallelism, asymmetric accommodation. Social and political processes of Transylvania Hungarians). Magyar Kisebbség 20. (1-2): 30-64.
Kovács, M. 2007. The politics of dual citizenship. Dual Citizenship in Global Perspective: from Unitary to Multiple Citizenship. In Dual Citizenship in Global Perspective. Eds.: Faist, T. and Kivisto, P., New York, Palgrave-MacMillan. 92-112.
Kovály, K. and Čermáková, D. 2016. The role of social capital in economic life of the Ukrainian entrepreneurs in Czechia. AUC Geographica 51. (2): 135-144. Crossref
Kovály, K., Erőss, Á. and Tátrai, P. 2017. "Hát megpróbálunk küzdeni": átalakuló boldogulási stratégiák Kárpátalján az Euromajdan után ("So we try to strive": livelihood strategies in transition after the Euromaidan in Transcarpathia, Ukraine). Tér és Társadalom 31. (2): 3-22. Crossref
Kulu, H. 2000. Policy towards the Diaspora and Ethnic (Return) Migration: An Estonian case. GeoJournal 51. (3): 135-143. Crossref
Lendel, M. 2015. Migration to V4 countries: A Ukrainian Perspective. In Current Migration trends in V4 countries: Focus on migration from Ukraine. Ed.: Benč, V., Prešov, Research Centre of the Slovak Foreign Policy Association, 9-20.
Leontiyeva, Y. 2014. The Education-Employment Mismatch among Ukrainian Migrants in the Czech Republic. Central and Eastern European Migration Review 3. (1): 63-84.
Melegh, A. 2002. Globalization, nationalism and petit imperialism. Romanian Journal of Society and Politics 2. (1): 115-129.
Melegh, A. 2016. Unequal Exchanges and the Radicalization of Demographic Nationalism in Hungary. Transactions. East European Journal of Society and Politics 2. (4): 87-108.
Molnár, J. and Molnár, D.I. 2005. Kárpátalja népessége és magyarsága a népszámlálási és népmozgalmi adatoktükrében (Demographic process of ethnic Hungarians in Transcarpathia). Uzhhorod, Kárpátaljai Magyar Pedagógusszövetség.
MPAJ 2011. Policy for Hungarian Communities Abroad - The Strategic Framework for Hungarian Communities Abroad . Budapest, Ministry of Public Administration and Justice (MPAJ), State Secretariat for Hungarian Communities Abroad.
Nagy, B. 2014. Az állampolgárság mint stigma: az állampolgárság hátrányai (Citizenship as stigma: the drawbacks of citizenship). Regio 22. (1): 36-73.
Papp, Z.A. 2017. Trickster Logic in the Hungarian Citizenship Offer. Nationalism and Ethnic Politics 23. (1): 18-32. Crossref
Perchinig, B. and Bauböck, R. 2005. Preface. In Acquisition and Loss of Nationality. Policies and Trends in 15 European States. Volume 2: Country Analyses. IMISCOE Research. Eds.: Bauböck, R., Ersboll, E., Groenendijk, K. and Waldrauch, H., Amsterdam, Amsterdam University Press, 11-17.
Pogonyi, S. 2011. Dual citizenship and sovereignty. Nationaliaties Papers 39. (5): 685-704. Crossref
Pogonyi, S. 2014. Four Patterns of Non-resident Voting Rights. Ethnopolitics 13. (2): 122-140. Crossref
Pogonyi, S. 2015. Transborder Kin-minority as Symbolic Resource in Hungary. Journal on Ethnopolitics and Minority Issues in Europe 14. (3): 73-98.
Pogonyi, S. 2017. Europanization of Kin-Citizenship and the Dynamics of Kin-Minority Claim-Making: The Case of Hungary. In Problems of Post-Communism. Published online 07.06.2017.
Pogonyi, S., Kovács, M. and Körtvélyesi, Z. 2010. "The Politics of External Kin-State Citizenship in Eastern Europe." EUDO Citizenship Observatory. San Domenico di Fiesole, European University Institute. Available at:
Shevel, O. 2010. Country Report: Ukraine. EUDO Citizenship Observatory. San Domenico di Fiesole, European University Institute.
Sievers, W. 2009. `A call to kinship?` Citizenship and migration in the new Member States and the accession countries of the EU. In Citizenship Policies in the New Europe. IMISCOE Research. Eds.: Bauböck, R., Perchinig, B. and Wiebke, S., Amsterdam, Amsterdam University Press, 439-457.
Soltész, B. and Zimmerer, G. 2014. Migration between the EU, V4 and Eastern Europe: the present situation and possible future. The perspective of Hungary. In Forecasting Migration Between the EU, V4 and Eastern Europe. Impact of Visa abolition. Eds.: Jaroszewicz, M. and Lesińska, M., Warsaw, Centre for Eastern Studies. 122-138.
Tóth, J. 2006. Kin Minority, Kin-state and Neighbourhood Policy in the Enlarged Europe. In Beyond Sovereignty: From Status Law to Transnational Citizenship? Eds.: Ieda, O. et al. Sapporo, Slavic Research Centre, Hokkaido University, 73-88.
Uherek, Z. 2016. Migration from Ukraine to the Czech Republic with Respect to the War Conflict in Eastern Ukraine . Warsaw, Centre of Migration Research. CMR Working Papers 93.
Waterbury, M.A. 2009. From Irredentism to Diaspora Politics: States and Transborder Ethnic Groups in Eastern Europe . Global Migration and Transnational Politics Working Paper 6.
Waterbury, M.A. 2010. Between State and Nation. Diaspora Politics and Kin-state Nationalism in Hungary. New York, Palgrave MacMillan.
Waterbury, M.A. 2014. Making Citizens Beyond the Borders. Non-resident Ethnic Citizenship in Post-Communist Europe. Problems of Post-Communism 61. (4): 36-49. Crossref
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.