Environmental Duties and Liability in the Constitution of Slovakia

  • Lívia TRELLOVÁ Prof. JUDr., PhD., Full Professor, Comenius University in Bratislava, Faculty of Law
  • Tomáš STRÉMY Prof. JUDr., PhD., Full Professor, Comenius University in Bratislava, Faculty of Law

Absztrakt

The article addresses the constitutional protection of the environment in the Slovak Republic, focusing in particular on an analysis of Arts. 44 and 45 of the Constitution of the Slovak Republic and their application in practice. From the perspective of Slovak legal doctrine, this constitutional framework is embedded in a broader development, whereby environmental law is increasingly regarded as a distinct and internally coherent branch of law within the national legal system. Attention is given to the obligations of the state, the obligations of the individual, constitutional liability, as well as to the issues of enforceability of these rights and obligations. The basis for the constitutional analysis lies in the constitutional and statutory regulation of the right to a favourable environment and the right to information on the environment, complemented by a systematic interpretation of the decision-making activity of the Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic in the context of the principles of the rule of law. The authors place special emphasis on addressing the constitutional dilemma concerning the nature, content and scope of the right to a favourable environment, as regulated and interpreted within the Slovak constitutional system, and its interconnection with other fundamental rights which determine its practical enforceability. The contribution further presents selected examples of good application practice and formulates “de constitutio ferenda” proposals aimed at strengthening the constitutional regulation of environmental protection as a fundamental element of an individual’s life within a modern society, with regard to the constitutional regulation of environmental obligations and liability.

Hivatkozások

Cibulka Ľ et al. (2014) Ústavné právo (ústavný systém Slovenskej republiky), Právnická fakulta Univerzity Komenského, Bratislava.

Čič M et al. (2012) Komentár k Ústave Slovenskej republiky, Eurokódex, Bratislava.

Chalabi A (2023) A New Theoretical Model of the Right to Environment and its Practical Advantages, Human Rights Law Review 23(4), pp. 1–19, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/hrlr/ngad023.

Chládeková M (2024) Vnútroštátne súdy majú kľúčovú úlohu v konaniach týkajúcich sa klimatickej zmeny (z judikatúry ESĽP), Bulletin Slovenskej advokácie 3/2024, pp. 46–47.

Drgonec J (2019) Ústava Slovenskej republiky, Nakladateľstvo C.H.Beck, Bratislava.

Ministerstvo vnútra SR (2025) Environmentálna kriminalita, https://www.minv.sk/?environmentalna-kriminalita [16.09.2025].

Commitee of Ministers (2025) H46-30 Verein KlimaSeniorinnen Schweiz and Others v. Switzerland (Application No. 53600/20), Supervision of the execution of the European Court’s judgements, Reference document, CM/Notes/1521/H46-30, https://tinyurl.com/5n899k9e [16.09.2025].

Generálna prokuratúra SR (2025) Hodnotia správa o úsmom kole vzájomných hodnotení „Praktické vykonávanie a uplatňovanie európskych politík v oblasti predchádzania trestnej činnosti proti životnému prostrediu a boja proti nej” – správa o Slovensku, https://www.genpro.gov.sk/extdoc/7370 [16.09.2025].

Jakab R (2023) Prohibition of cross – border water transport in the conditions of the Slovak Republic and its legal consequences, JAEL 18(35), pp. 49–63, DOI: https://doi.org/10.21029/JAEL.2023.35.49.

Vasak K (1984) Pour une troisème generation des droits del’homme, in: Swinarski C (ed.) Studies and Essays on International Humanitarian Law and Red Cross Principles, ICRC & Nijhoff, n.p., pp. 837–845.

Krošlák D et al. (2016) Ústavné právo, Wolters Kluwer, Bratislava.

Maslen M (2023) Waste management and its possible development in the Slovak Republic, JAEL 18(34), pp. 73–90, DOI: https://doi.org/10.21029/JAEL.2023.34.73.

Maslen M (2022) Slovak Republic: Constitution and the Protection of Environment and Natural Resources, in Szilágyi J E (ed.) Constitutional Protection of the Environment and Future Generations, Central European Academic Publishing, Miskolc – Budapest, pp. 399–437.

Michalovič M & Maslen M (2024) Advocating for environmental law – grounds for its status as an independent branch of law in Slovak legal doctrine, Prawne Problemy Górnictwa i Ochrany Środowiska 2/2024, pp. 1–26, DOI: https://doi.org/10.31261/PPGOS.2024.02.06.

Mathevet R, Bousquet F, Larrère C & Larrère R (2018) Environmental Stewardship and Ecological Solidarity: Rethinking Social-Ecological Interdependency and Responsibility, J. Agric. Environ. Ethic 31(2), pp. 605–623, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10806-018-9749-0.

Moyano-Fernández M (2022) Building Ecological Solidarity: Rewilding Practices as an Example, Philosophies 7(4), pp. 1–14, DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/philosophies7040077.

CCPE (2022) Opinion No. 17 (2022) of the Consultative Council of European Prosecutors to the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe: The Role of Prosecutors in the Protection of the Environment, https://rm.coe.int/opinion-no-17-2022-slovak/1680b4bc0a [16.09.2025].

Orosz L, Svák J et al. (2023) Ústava Slovenskej republiky. Komentár. Zväzok III., Wolters Kluwer s.r.o., Bratislava.

Orosz L, Svák J et al. (2021) Ústava Slovenskej republiky. Komentár. Zväzok I., Wolters Kluwer s.r.o., Bratislava.

Orosz L, Svák J et al. (2022) Ústava Slovenskej republiky. Komentár. Zväzok II., Wolters Kluwer s.r.o., Bratislava.

Szilágyi J E (2022) Constitutional Protection of the Environment and Future Generations in Certain Central European Countries, in Szilágyi JE (ed.) Constitutional Protection of the Environment and Future Generations, Central European Academic Publishing, Miskolc–Budapest, pp. 479–526.

Sládeček V et al. (2016) Ústava České republiky. Komentář, 2nd edn., C. H. Beck, Praha.

ECA (2021) Special Report 12/2021: Zásada „znečisťovateľ platí”: nejednotné uplatňovanie v rámci politík a opatrení EÚ v oblasti životného prostredia, https://www.eca.europa.eu/lists/ecadocuments/sr21_12/sr_polluter_pays_principle_sk.pdf. [19.05.2024].

Generálna prokuratúra SR (2023) Správa generálneho prokurátora Slovenskej republiky o činnosti prokuratúry a poznatkoch prokuratúry o stave zákonnosti v Slovenskej republike za rok 2023, https://www.genpro.gov.sk/fileadmin/Sprava_o_cinnosti/2023/vlastny_material.pdf [16.09.2025].

Svák J (2021) Nadnárodné systémy ochrany ľudských práv, III. Zväzok. Ochrana súkromia a majetku, Wolters Kluwer SR s.r.o., Bratislava.

Trellová L (2015) Ústavnoprávna regulácia starostlivosti o životné prostredie, in: Cepek B et al. (eds.) Environmentálne právo. Všeobecná a osobitná časť, Vydavatelství a nakladatelství Aleš Čeněk, Plzeň.

Trellová L (2013) Ochrana životného prostredia v Ústave Slovenskej republiky a jej vybrané aspekty, Míľniky práva v stredoeurópskom priestore 2013, 1. časť, Univerzita Komenského, Právnická fakulta, Bratislava, pp. 223–229.

SIŽP (2025) Trestnoprávna zodpovednosť, https://www.sizp.sk/priroda/ochrana-prirody-a-krajiny/trestnopravnazodpovednost [16.09.2025].

Vasak K (1977) A 30-Year Struggle, UNESCO Courier, https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000046193 [16.09.2025].

Case law

Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic (1996) Finding no. II. ÚS 8/96 of 4 September 1996.

Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic (2003) Finding no. I. ÚS 4/02 z 9 July 2003.

Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic (2009) Finding no. PL. ÚS 3/03 z 28 January 2009.

Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic (2008) Finding no. 22/06 z 1 October 2008.

Constitution al Court of the Slovak Republic (2008) Finding no. II. ÚS 93/08 zo 6 March 2008.

Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic (2008) Finding no. III. ÚS 100/08 z 1 April 2008.

Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic (2009) Finding no. PL. ÚS 14/06 z 23 September 2009.

Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic (2014) Finding no. I. ÚS 73/2014 of 5 March 2014.

Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic (2014) Finding no. PL. ÚS 10/2013 of 10 December 2014.

Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic (2015) Finding no. III. ÚS 352/2015 of 14 July 2015.

Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic (2019) Finding no. II. ÚS 107/2019 of 6 June 2019.

Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic (2020) Finding no. I. ÚS 174/2020 of 16 April 2020.

Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic (2021) Finding no. I. ÚS 529/2019 of 19 January 2021.

Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic (2025) Finding no. PL. ÚS 2/2025 of 15 January 2025.

Constitutional Court of the Slovak Republic (2015) Finding no. I. ÚS 7/2014 of 11 June 2015.

ECHR (2005) J. A. Pye (Oxford) v. the United Kingdom, Application no. 44302/02.

CJEU (2013) Judgment in Case C-416/10 of 15 January 2013.

ECHR (1994) López Ostra v. Spain, Application no. 16798/90.

ECHR (2024) Verein KlimaSeniorinnen Schweiz and Others v. Switzerland, Application no. 53600/20, 9 April.

SC SR (2018) Judgment Case No. 10Asan/5/2017 of 27 April 2018.

Megjelent
2026-06-24
Rovat
Cikkek